Issues with Matthew
Matthean Revision to Mark
Arguments for Markan Priority with Respect to Matthew
Although Synoptic scholars debate the exact relationship between Mark and Luke, modern New Testament scholarship is virtually unanimous that Matthew used the Gospel of Mark as a written Greek source. As Warren Carter observes in Matthew: Storyteller, Interpreter, Evangelist (rev. ed., Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers; Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2004, pp. 53–54), Matthew incorporates all but roughly 55 of Mark’s 661 verses and reproduces approximately 8,555 of Mark’s 11,078 Greek words:
“Matthew transmits, reinterprets, and reformulates Mark in five ways: (1) omitting, (2) adding and expanding, (3) reordering, (4) abbreviating, and (5) improving style.” (Warren Carter, Matthew: Storyteller, Interpreter, Evangelist, rev. ed., 2004, p. 54)
Omitting Markan Material
Analyzing Matthew’s omissions across Markan parallels (pp. 55–57), Carter demonstrates how the First Evangelist systematically removes details that might compromise either the majesty of Jesus or the reputation of the Twelve:
- Human emotions and frustration: Whereas the Markan Jesus displays raw human emotion, anger, grief, and impatience, Matthew regularly excises or softens these traits—compare Jesus looking around “with anger, grieved at their hardness of heart” in Mark 3:5 (omitted in Matthew 12:12–13) or sighing deeply in his spirit in Mark 8:12 (omitted in Matthew 12:39 and Matthew 16:2–4).
- Apparent limitations on Jesus’ power: Matthew alters passages suggesting that external circumstances constrained Jesus’ ability to act—changing Mark 6:5 (“he could do no mighty work there”) into Matthew 13:58 (“he did not do many mighty works there, because of their unbelief”), omitting Mark 6:48 (“he meant to pass by them”; cf. Matthew 14:25), and dropping the two-stage healing of the blind man at Bethsaida altogether (Mark 8:22–26).
- Questions implying ignorance: Mark’s Jesus frequently asks genuine information-seeking questions—such as “Who touched my garments?” (Mark 5:30; omitted in Matthew 9:20–22) or “What are you discussing with them?” (Mark 9:16; omitted in Matthew 17:14–18)—whereas Matthew portrays Jesus as already knowing the situation and exercising sovereign control.
- Rehabilitation of the disciples: Where Mark depicts the disciples as obtuse, fearful, and self-seeking (e.g., Mark 4:13; Mark 6:52; Mark 9:6, 10, 32; Mark 10:35–37), Matthew softens their failures so that the Twelve—while still imperfect learners—model receptive understanding (Matthew 13:16–18, 51; Matthew 14:33; Matthew 16:12) and shift the ambitious request of James and John onto their mother (Matthew 20:20–21).
Adding and Expanding Material
Alongside strategic omissions, Carter highlights how Matthew expands Mark’s narrative framework by inserting five major teaching discourses—chapters 5–7, 10, 13, 18, and 23–25—each closed by a stereotyped transition formula (pp. 58–61). Some discourses enlarge Markan nuclei (comparing Matthew 13 with Mark 4, and Matthew 23–25 with Mark 13), while others interrupt Mark’s sequence to supply extensive instruction on ethics, mission, and church discipline (Matthew 5–7; Matthew 10; Matthew 18). For example, Matthew 18:1–9 adapts Mark 9:33–50 (while omitting Mark 9:38–40 and relocating Mark 9:41 to Matthew 10:42), then inserts twenty-six verses of community regulation (Matthew 18:10–35) before resuming Mark 10 at Matthew 19:1.
Similarly, to construct the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7), the evangelist interrupts Mark 1:21–22—replacing Mark’s Capernaum synagogue setting with a Mosaic mountain setting (Matthew 5:1–2; cf. Exodus 19–20)—and only reconnects with Mark 1:22 three chapters later at Matthew 7:28–29, adding “the crowds” and his signature closing clause, “And when Jesus finished these sayings” (repeated at Matthew 11:1; Matthew 13:53; Matthew 19:1; and, reinforced with “all,” at Matthew 26:1; Carter, pp. 58–59).
On a smaller scale, Matthew introduces characteristic redactional vocabulary—such as “little faith” (oligopistos), “hypocrite” (hypokritēs), “righteousness” (dikaiosynē), and “lawlessness” (anomia)—to shape his audience’s ethical identity. Building on Sir John C. Hawkins’s classic list of ninety-five distinctively Matthean words and phrases (Horae Synopticae: Contributions to the Study of the Synoptic Problem, 2nd ed. [Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1909], pp. 4–8), W. D. Davies and Dale C. Allison Jr. catalog more than two hundred characteristic Matthean expressions (A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Gospel According to Saint Matthew, vol. 1, International Critical Commentary [Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1988], pp. 75–79; see also Ulrich Luz, Matthew 1–7, Hermeneia [Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1989], pp. 52–73; Robert H. Gundry, Matthew: A Commentary on His Handbook for a Mixed Church under Persecution, 2nd ed. [Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1994], pp. 1–5, 641–649). As Carter concludes, this pervasive redactional vocabulary underscores Matthew’s sustained theological focus on Christology, eschatology, Torah ethics, and ecclesiology (p. 61).
Reordering Material
Matthew also substantially rearranges Mark’s narrative sequence across Matthew 3:1–13:58 (corresponding to Mark 1–6) in order to group deeds and teachings thematically (Carter, pp. 61–64). Opening his triad of miracle cycles in chapters 8–9, Matthew bypasses Mark 1:23–28 and Mark 1:35–39 and moves the cleansing of the leper (Mark 1:40–45) ahead of the healings of Peter’s mother-in-law and the evening crowds (Mark 1:29–34) so that it stands first in Matthew 8:1–4. Following Daniel J. Harrington (The Gospel of Matthew, Sacra Pagina 1 [Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1991], pp. 114–115), Carter notes that placing Jesus’ command to show himself to the priest and offer the gift commanded by Moses (Matthew 8:4; cf. Leviticus 14) immediately after the Sermon on the Mount visually enacts Jesus’ declaration in Matthew 5:17–20 that he came not to abolish the Law but to fulfill it (pp. 62–64).
Donald Senior summarizes two overarching arguments that confirm this direction of literary dependence in The Gospel of Matthew (Interpreting Biblical Texts [Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1997], p. 22). First, if Mark had worked from Matthew (and Luke), it would be inexplicable why he excised virtually all of Jesus’ major discourses—such as the Sermon on the Mount and the Lord’s Prayer—along with the birth and resurrection appearance narratives. Second, wherever Matthew and Mark overlap, Matthew consistently polishes Mark’s rough colloquial Greek and removes potential theological stumbling blocks:
“It is more convincing to suggest that Matthew improved upon Mark’s Greek, rather than Mark downgrading Matthew’s superior style. The same holds true for a number of places where Matthew appears to upgrade Mark’s content or to eliminate passages in Mark that were possibly offensive or objectionable to his community.” (Donald Senior, The Gospel of Matthew, Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1997, p. 22)
James Moffatt on Matthew’s Editorial Changes to Mark
Early in the twentieth century, Scottish New Testament scholar James Moffatt cataloged these same redactional patterns in An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament (International Theological Library [Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1911], pp. 248–249), showing how Matthew’s later ecclesiastical perspective reshapes Mark’s portrait of the Twelve and of Jesus:
“The later and more ecclesiastical standpoint of Matthew comes out definitely in his recasting of the Marcan traditions relating to the disciples and Jesus. The former play a more important role than in Mark; thus the saying about the spiritual family of Jesus is confined to them [the disciples] (Matt 12:49) instead of being addressed generally to the bystanders (Mark 3:34–35). Mt. minimizes the faults of the disciples (Matt 13:16–18 with Mark 4:13, cp. Matt 13:51; Matt 14:33 with Mark 6:52; Matt 16:9–12 with Mark 8:17–22; cp. the significant omission of Mark 9:6, Mark 9:10, Mark 9:32, the smoothing down of Mark 9:33–34 in Matt 18:1, the change of Mark 10:32 in Matt 20:17 etc.), and endeavours to eliminate or to soften any trait derogatory to the credit of the twelve. A similar reverence for the character of Jesus appears in his omission of words or passages like Mark 1:43, Mark 3:5, Mark 3:21 (charge of madness), [Mark] 10:14, and [Mark] 11:3, and in changes like those of Matt 19:16–17 (Mark 10:17–18) and Matt 26:59–61 (cp. Mark 14:58). The miraculous power of Jesus is heightened (contrast Matt 8:16 with Mark 1:32–33, Matt 17:17–18 with Mark 9:20–26 etc.), and the author shrinks as far as possible from allowing demons to recognize him as the Messiah; the prophetic power of Jesus is also expanded and made more definite (cp. Matt 7:15, Matt 12:45, Matt 21:43, Matt 24:10, Matt 26:2 etc.).” (James Moffatt, An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament, Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1911, pp. 248–249)
Robert Lindsey: Markan Defects Inherited by Matthew
In A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark (2nd ed., Jerusalem: Dugith Publishers, 1973), Jerusalem scholar Robert Lisle Lindsey recounted how translating Mark into idiomatic Hebrew alongside a Greek Synopsis led him to question both Markan primacy over Luke and Matthew’s independence from Luke:
“I therefore turned to a story-by-story, word-by-word, study of the Synoptic Gospels of Matthew, Mark, and Luke… To my surprise it turned out that Luke’s Gospel contained almost none of the non-Hebraic expressions so common in Mark! On the other hand Matthew, when copying Mark (or if copying Mark), appeared to reject about half the non-Hebraisms of Mark completely, to accept others without question and repeat them in exact Markan contexts, and to reject still others in the earlier chapters of his Gospel only to accept them in later portions.
Having long supposed that Luke, as the non-Jewish companion of Paul, tended to modify his text to make it more understandable to Greeks of pagan background, I was even more surprised to note that the Lukan text was almost always easier to translate to idiomatic Hebrew than was Mark. After several more years of study in which this observation has been confirmed again and again, I today find my early supposition amusing, but the point is that I was quite unprepared to suppose that of all the Synoptists Luke should prove to be the best in preservation of earlier texts.
An even stranger conclusion, if this is possible, began during these early days of research to force its way into my consciousness: where Matthew was parallel to Mark and Luke in any given story or sentence many, but not all, of the Markan translation difficulties reappeared in Matthew in the same or a somewhat modified form, but where Matthew was not parallel to Mark (whether in the stories only Luke and Matthew share or in those given only by Matthew) his text showed the same ease of translation as that of Luke.” (Robert L. Lindsey, A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark, Jerusalem: Dugith Publishers, 1973, p. 12)
Lindsey was struck by a consistent pattern: in triple-tradition pericopes Matthew carries over distinctively Markan non-Semitic idioms, whereas in non-Markan parallels Matthew’s Greek reflects the same Semitic syntax preserved throughout Luke. Whether one attributes that underlying tradition to canonical Luke or to an earlier Lukan proto-narrative, Matthew stands downstream from Mark’s editorial reworking.
Lindsey’s Reassessment of the Synoptic Problem
Exploring the consequences of this finding, Lindsey observed that Mark could no longer be treated as the sole primitive narrative behind both Matthew and Luke:
“Without quite realizing it and quite without intending it, I thus found myself questioning whether our Mark could, in fact, be the principal narrative source standing equally behind Matthew and Luke in their so-called Markan portions. It looked as if Luke had universally copied more faithfully whatever Greek sources he had and that these had been translated earlier from a Hebrew source or sources, or at least from some Semitic document or documents so much like Hebrew that in retranslation it was impossible to tell the difference. It also looked as if Matthew had indeed used Mark’s Gospel with all its redactic expressions but had rejected many of these for some reason I could not yet explain…” (Lindsey, A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark, 1973, pp. 12–13)
In Lindsey’s reconstruction, Matthew demonstrably used Mark—inheriting characteristic Markan redactional phrases—while also drawing on a Lukan or proto-Lukan narrative stream that predated Matthew.
The Minor Agreements
In Synoptic criticism, the “Minor Agreements” are verbal concurrences between Matthew and Luke against Mark within triple-tradition passages. By testing whether these agreements reflect Greek stylistic coincidence or underlying Hebrew syntax, Lindsey concluded that Matthew was “dependent on a text like Luke (if not Luke)” (p. 17) and summarized four conclusions:
“1. The Minor Agreements help to clarify the strong dependence of Luke on a non-Markan text.
2. The Minor Agreements help to clarify the redactic methods of Mark, for they show us exactly what some of the words and phrases are which Mark rejects and we are able to study his replacement terms and expressions in these cases.
3. The Minor Agreements help to clarify the methods of Matthew when faced with more than one parallel account: it is clear that he combines his texts by alternately choosing phrases, first from one text and then from the next, with the result that he achieves a kind of interwoven effect. We may quite rightly call this Matthaean achievement a Weave Effect, though we must not suppose that Matthew’s text alone can be described in this fashion; Mark’s redactive methods produced a similar effect.
4. The Minor Agreements help us to clarify the nature of the early narrative which apparently lies behind all the Synoptic Gospels. This proto-narrative is certainly best seen in Luke but can be partially seen in Matthew in his Minor Agreements with Luke in Markan contexts and may appear in Matthew’s highly Hebraic texts which are consistently found in non-Markan contexts. This undertext shows some signs of annotation and editing by a Greek writer but apparently preserves within it a highly literal Greek translation of a Hebrew original.” (Lindsey, A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark, 1973, pp. 17–18)
Comparing the triple tradition as a whole, Lindsey noted a “great difference between Matthew and Luke as to the amount of their respective dependence on Mark,” reiterating that “the text of Luke turns out to be Semitically better than either Mark or Matthew in the Triple Tradition” (p. 19).
Key Questions on Literary Order
Reflecting on why he had initially assumed Markan priority over Luke, Lindsey wrote:
“My failure even to ask whether the Mk–Lk relationship had been correctly apprehended undoubtedly stemmed from the fact that I was insufficiently aware of any serious contenders to the theory of Markan Priority and was also probably due to my predilection to think of Luke as the Gentile Christian modifier of the earlier Gospel sources, an idea I must have picked up long ago in the usual ways of untested deduction.
For instance, the fact that Luke preserves a Greek text which normally retranslates easily to Hebrew and almost always fails to give even a hint of an expression which could be interpreted as the remnant of a Markan non-Hebraism should have led me to suspect that Luke is uninfluenced by Mark and derives his usually excellent translation-text directly from a proto-source. I should also have asked why a writer like Mark, who enjoyed re-writing as much as he did, should not have been deliberately changing the wording not only of his proto-narrative but also of Luke, thus becoming the creator of the strange verbal distance between Matthew and Luke.” (Lindsey, A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark, 1973, p. 26)
For Lindsey, the decisive clue was that Luke maintains a uniform Semitic-Greek translation register, whereas Matthew appears “to be weaving together Markan redactic phrases and PN [Proto-Narrative] expressions” (p. 27).
David Flusser: Synoptic Examples Confirming Matthew’s Dependence on Mark
In his foreword to Lindsey’s volume, David Flusser of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem illustrated how Second Temple Jewish legal practice (halakhah, the body of Jewish religious law governing daily observance, Sabbath conduct, and adjudication) illuminates the secondary character of Mark and Matthew relative to Luke:
“If we follow Lindsey’s [analysis] of the Synoptic situation it is not surprising that we often find many evidences to suggest that Luke’s version is the most accurate and that Matthew has been too often unduly influenced by Mark, even when he is correcting Mark by his parallel texts. The story of the Man with the Withered Hand (Mark 3:1–6 and parallels) is a case in point. In the story Jesus’ opponents watch to see if he will heal a man on the Sabbath in a way opposed to the halacha. None of the Synoptists suggest that there was any open criticism of Jesus’ action. There is no discoverable reason why there should have been such a criticism, for this kind of healing (by command) was not in opposition to the halacha. Yet both Mark and Matthew, in almost identical words, state that ‘the Pharisees’ (Mark adds also ‘the Herodians’) took counsel against Jesus ‘to destroy him.’ Luke significantly says only that Jesus’ opponents ‘discussed among themselves’ what to do ‘to’ Jesus…
The incident in the Gospels must have occurred much as Luke has stated it. Jesus looks at the unfortunate man and in provoking challenge to all present says, ‘Is it permitted to do good or to do evil on the Sabbath, to save life or destroy it?’ He then tells the man to stretch out his hand and as he does so the hand is healed. There is certainly an implied criticism of Sabbath legalism in Jesus’ words but he has done nothing wrong. Luke’s ‘they discussed what to do to Jesus’ may only mean ‘they discussed what could be done to Jesus.’… Mark, however, takes the phrase to mean that ‘they counseled with each other’ with a view to doing what a later group of high priests would counsel together to do, namely, destroy Jesus. Mark has leapt ahead to a later event and attributed motives of a later time to the detractors of Jesus who… are unhappy with the seeming imprudence of Jesus.” (David Flusser, “Foreword,” in Robert L. Lindsey, A Hebrew Translation of the Gospel of Mark, Jerusalem: Dugith Publishers, 1973, pp. 4–5)
Flusser drew three methodological lessons from this comparison:
“The first [lesson] is that any normal philological reasoning would indicate the priority or greater authenticity of Luke’s accounts. Water does not flow uphill. It is simply impossible to believe that the Matthaean-Markan account could be changed secondarily into the Lukan form… The second lesson is that understanding of the language usages of Jesus’ time can quite often throw immediate light on questions of originality in our Gospels. The third is that Matthew is indeed secondary to Mark and Mark to Luke, for only in such an order of dependence can we see how Matthew can accept the secondary oddity of the Markan text.” (Flusser, “Foreword,” in Lindsey, 1973, p. 5)
Flusser added a second major illustration from the Sanhedrin interrogation of Jesus (Luke 22:66–71 vs. Mark 14:55–64 and Matthew 26:59–66):
“The high originality of Luke and the secondary character of Mark (so often repeated in Matthew) can be further illustrated in one of the most important areas of the Gospel story, the so-called trial of Jesus. Most of the difficulties which have plagued students of the ‘trial’ have come as a result of the concentration of scholars on the Matthaean-Markan version of this event to the neglect of Luke. I want here only to mention two important points connected with the discussion…
In the Gospel of Luke, no mention of a condemnation of Jesus by the Jewish authorities is recorded. This is of special interest in view of the failure of Luke to follow Mark in such a mention either at the point of the ‘trial’ or in the recording of Jesus’ third prophecy of his demise in Jerusalem… Luke does not hesitate to report the delivery of Jesus to Pilate by the Jewish authorities yet does not mention the Markan ‘condemnation,’ and when we note that Mark’s ‘all judged him worthy of death’ (Mark 14:64) can easily be Mark’s interpretation and extension of the conclusion of the high priest’s decision in Luke 22:71.
The second point concerns the Matthaean-Markan agreement that the high priests accused Jesus of blasphemy. Scholars have labored long and lovingly to explain what might have been the nature of this blasphemy… None of our Synoptic materials give any facts which clarify the charge of blasphemy. The accusation of blasphemy is absent from Luke, as is the Markan reference to the tearing of the high priest’s clothes. There is only an interrogation by the high priests and a most remarkable description of Jesus’ dialogue with the priests the rabbinic sophistication of which is not less astounding than the Hebrew word order and idiom of the account. There is every reason to accept the Lukan version in preference to that of Matthew and Mark.” (Flusser, “Foreword,” in Lindsey, 1973, pp. 6–7)
Statistical Evidence from Double-Tradition and Triple-Tradition Parallels
In the second installment of a four-part statistical study of the Synoptic Problem in Jerusalem Perspective (building on his first article on the Triple Tradition), Halvor Ronning compares Matthew’s verbal agreement rates across Double Tradition (DT, material shared by two Synoptic Gospels alone) and Triple Tradition (TT, material shared by all three). Ronning demonstrates why Matthew’s verbal overlap with Luke drops sharply precisely when Mark is present as an intermediary:
“This scenario gives a totally consistent picture of Matthew in three of the four contexts. The exception is when Matthew writes a story that has a parallel not only in Luke, but also in Mark. Then Matthew’s average of verbal identity with Mark remains high (48% as just indicated), but Matthew’s average of verbal identity with Luke drops radically from 47% to 20%, just because Mark happens to have the same stories! This is a radical change because it is less than half of Matthew’s average verbal identity with Luke in those parallels shared with Luke alone without the presence of Mark.
This radical change is elegantly explained by the Luke→Mark→Matthew scenario. The dramatic shift between Matthew’s ability to replicate approximately 50% of Luke’s wording when there is no parallel in Mark to a 20% rate when Mark is parallel to Luke is explained as Matthew’s continuing in precisely the same overall steady faithfulness to his sources as always. It becomes clear that it is precisely Matthew’s faithfulness to Mark, the immediate source before him, which was the very cause of the distance from Luke.
Matthew is consistent in his average use of Mark’s wording whether Luke has a parallel or not. It is Mark’s relationship to Luke that causes the distance, not Matthew’s relationship to Luke. It has nothing to do with any change in Matthew’s attitude toward Lukan material. Matthew treats Lukan material the same way he treats Markan material: with the same consistent 50% average—as long as Mark is not present. But since Matthew has chosen (for whatever reason) to follow the Markan material as primary, this decision causes Matthew himself automatically to reflect Mark’s distance from Luke. Indeed it is precisely the amount of distance from Luke that demonstrates the fact that Matthew got nearly all of his Lukan words in Triple Tradition [through] Mark, because the amount of distance fits so perfectly with what could be predicted from Matthew’s use of Markan wording.
It is most impressive to note the near perfect predictability of the distance between Matthew and Luke precisely because Matthew kept relating exactly the same way to Markan material whether Luke was present or not. Since Mark’s wording has only a 32% relationship to Luke’s TT material, and Matthew has a 50% relationship to Mark’s material, this allowed us to predict that Matthew’s relationship to Lukan material would drop to 16%, because the Lukan material is not coming directly to Matthew, but only through Mark as the intermediary.” (Halvor Ronning, “A Statistical Approach to the Synoptic Problem: Part 2—Double Tradition,” Jerusalem Perspective, May 18, 2016)
Conclusion: Matthew’s Special Narrative Additions
Assessing the narrative episodes peculiar to Matthew in The Origins of the Gospel According to St. Matthew (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1946; repr. Wauconda, IL: Bolchazy-Carducci Publishers, 2007, p. 55), G. D. Kilpatrick classifies the evangelist’s special narrative additions into five categories:
- (a) The Nativity stories (Matthew 1–2);
- (b) Petrine stories: Matt 14:28–31, Matt 16:17–19, Matt 17:24–27, together with Matt 18:15–22 (cf. Matt 15:15);
- (c) Passion and Resurrection stories: Matt 26:52–54, Matt 27:3–10, Matt 27:19, Matt 27:24–25, Matt 27:51–53, Matt 27:62–66, Matt 28:2–4, Matt 28:9–20;
- (d) Miscellaneous narratives: Matt 3:14–15, Matt 4:23–25, Matt 9:35, Matt 15:22–24, Matt 21:10–11, Matt 21:14–16 (cf. Matt 27:6); and
- (e) Formula quotations.
Surveying the first four narrative groups, Kilpatrick concludes that they represent late redactional and apologetic expansions built directly onto the spine of Mark rather than an independent early narrative source:
“Traces of the evangelist’s style have been marked. Where it was available, Mark provided the skeleton on which the various additions were built. There is a noticeable increase in the legendary and the marvelous. Apologetic and other motives for the late date appear. Several examples enable us to see the various stages of construction in the development of peculiar elements. All these facts taken together point to the conclusion that for this additional matter the editor had no written source before him.” (G. D. Kilpatrick, The Origins of the Gospel According to St. Matthew, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1946; repr. 2007, p. 55)
